I theorized last time that what’s been damning my chicken-work was not a lack of rigor, but too much of it. And so last night’s trial was as casual as a big chicken dinner ought to be. I wasn’t planning on frying at all—I was going to bake, to give my gut a break—but while searching for something to do with black eyed peas, I stumbled onto Cooks Illustrated’s recipe for oven fried chicken. “Oven fried?” I exclaimed to my empty bedroom. “That’s not even a thing!” And yet, apparently it is.
Discarding everything I’d decided about simple preparation, I decided to give their baroque breading a try. The chicken was to be dressed in crushed Melba toast, pulverized by the food processor I do not own. And so from the wild north of Manhattan I imported a sort of man-beast named Joseph to stand in for a Cuisinart. Using the bottom of a pint glass, a cup measurer, a chef’s knife, and finally his fists, he worked for twenty minutes to reduce the 5 ounces of surprisingly stubborn crackers into “sand and pebble texture.” The torrent of grunts and cursing caused the two ladies present to cover their ears, but their blushing was worth it for the resultant grease-free crunch. The chicken was excellent, and baking it was, as baking always is, easy. Like a cruise missile, the chicken was fire and forget. But unlike a cruise missile, it treated our stomachs gently. No one besides our uptown barbarian was fully incapacitated.
Of course, I didn’t mind toying with the chicken itself because the chicken is not the real experiment. Like the first caveman to don a labcoat, I am trying to invent fire. Past experiments have suggested that our best method is to refine the spicy paste that won the 2008 hot chicken cook off, and based on some work my mother and I did over Thanksgiving, it’s become clear that the first step to refining the paste is to make it not a paste at all. Combining the spices in butter instead of lard allows it to flow evenly all over the meat, and prevents clumps of pepper from forming. My wild man supervised the sauce, and though he added paprika, red pepper flakes and all sorts of other red things, the most crucial addition was approximately 1/8 of a pound of cayenne. I finally found someplace that sells it by weight: a market underneath the three chilli pepper Indian restaurants on First Avenue and 6th. A quarter pound bag costs $2.50 and a whole lot of mouth-ache.
That’s right! I said mouth-ache, because we finally crossed the pain threshold. We added the sauce in two different ways, spicing half the chicken while in the oven and half after we had taken it out. We thought baking it in would help some of the heat seep into the meat—a feat I’ve yet to accomplish—but instead it just dried it out, and cut down on the heat. Cooked cayenne hurts less, apparently. But pouring the molten sauce on chicken fresh out of the oven, then flipping it over and doing the other half, yielded evenly spiced meat that hurt like hell. I’d put it somewhere between Prince’s medium and hot, which means that in terms of heat, we’re actually about where I want to be.
The work is not yet done, of course, and will not be until the heat is seared straight through the meat. The next batch will spend the night before its debut soaking in a brine of water, salt, sugar and peppers. I’m skeptical that this will actually impart spice, but if nothing else it will make the meat more tender. But for those keeping track, here’s the rough formula for the Sauce That Worked:
- 1 stick butter
- 1/8 lb cayenne
- Some vegetable oil
- A bunch of other stuff
I’ll take leave now. The sun is falling and I need to get back before it gets really cold. Home is where the heat is, after all.
